Friday, December 7, 2012

Disc Injuries in Frontal, Side, and Rear-end Crashes

Disc Injuries in Frontal, Side, and Rear-end Crashes
         In a trail, two of the biomechanical and surgical opinions that defense experts often testify about are disc bulges and herniations after MVCs, proposing that all are preexisting phenomena and that single-event MVCs cannot cause herniations of the disc until after the spine fractures to some massive degree. One study often quoted by these experts as the basis for this opinion concluded, “With regard to the relationship between disc rupture and impact loading on the spine, it can be safely said that disc ruptures do not occur as the result of a single loading event, unless there are associated massive bony injuries to the spine.” Although controlled laboratory studies have shown that vertical compression of a spine are associated with bony fractures and disc injuries, this is not representative of real-world frontal, side, or rear impacts. It is deceptive to imply that vertical loading studies from pilots rejecting from airplanes, or two cadaver vertebrae (muscles removed) that are mounted on a testing device and then compressed until fracture/disc bulging occurs can be compared to horizontal loading in MVCs. In most collisions where rollovers do not occur, most of the forces are in the horizontal axis and the vertical components are significantly less. The sources that King cites used axial loading for their opinion or used cadaver spines that were not allowed all six-degrees of motion (flexion, extension, rotation in both directions, and lateral flexion in both directions).
               Post-traumatic disc injuries, including annular rears, disc fissures, disc bulging, and herniations are commonly seen in clinical practice. Many of these cases have a recent or prior history of being involved in a MVC. Invertebral disc injuries are routinely seen in occupants involved in rear-end and side collisions, and are seen less often and at higher delta-Vs in frontal impacts in my experience. Circumstances of the collision, occupant age, proneness to injury, out-of-position (OOP) issues, and other factors can change the delta-V threshold for any collision type. These disc injuries are seen in low-speed impacts as well as higher velocity crashes. Although some defense biomechanists and DMEs contend that it is impossible to herniated a human disc without previously fracturing vertebrae, this is not supported in cadaver tests that replicate real-world collisions using entire cadavers, which allow for typical human kinematic motion experienced in a MVC. Some defense experts who opine that the fracture of the vertebrae is a requirement for a traumatic disc herniation to occur may rely on airplane ejection studies that subjected the cadaver to rapid, high force vertical loading or used cadaver spines mounted on plates and forced into various motions. The majority of these tests did not allow the spine to move in all sex-degrees of freedom in same manner as seen in a MVC. For example, the spine may be compressed and analyzed for damage and then flexed in a separate test. Unfortunately, there has been little research of disc injuries following frontal, side, or rear-end crashes.
               I have seen several cases in my office where an MRI was taken of a person’s spine before and after an MVC, confirming a disc bulge. These pre-crash MRIs were usually taken to rule out the cause of a prior episode of neck or back pain with out without radiculopathy, and were found normal. In some instances there was a confirmed contained minimal disc bulge with post-collision MRI showing significantly larger disc protrusion with spinal cord impingement. The majority of disc injuries occur without concomitant fractures of the spine. However, there are many cases where the MRI will detect some degenerative changes in the disc or surrounding joint.
               It is common for a defense biomechanist or defense doctor to opine that the x-rays do not show any abnormalities, thus providing that there is no objective evidence of any injuries and all post-traumatic complaints were not due to the crash event. The assumption used by some of those defense experts is that if the x-ray looks normal, then the injury doesn’t exist. However, this premise has little scientific merit after a close examination of the available cadeveric research and the clinical literature.
               In fact, contrary to some defense theories, several real-world studies using cadaver spines that were allowed to move in all six degrees of motion showed that disc tears/hemorrhage and bulging often occur without any fractures of the spine. Taylor and Taylor performed autopsies of 109 humans who died following blunt trauma, where MVCs accounted for 72 of the fatalities, 34 from blows/falls, and 3 from sporting activities. The study noted that, “Most injuries involved the joints rather than the vertebrae; e.g., injuries to the discs were four times more frequent than fractures to the vertebrae.” The study also found that severe disc avulsions, disruptions, and traumatic herniations were located primarily at the C5-C6-C7 regions. There were almost equal numbers of disc injuries and facet injuries in the autopsy analysis. When determining the type of force vector from the police reports, 54% were from extension or extension-compression injuries and 27% from flexion or lateral-flexion injuries. The C2 and C6 vertebrae were the most common sites for fractures. In the upper cervical spine, bruising of the posterior synovial folds was the most common injury noted with hematoma around the C2 nerve. The study also compared radiologists’ diagnosis of 58 sets of x-rays with the findings at autopsy, concluding that the radiologist failed to detect 199 of the 309 lesions noted in autopsy.


Anonymous said...

com/images/themes/theme11/bgYou want to use a NATURAL join[url=]Howie Long Authentic Jersey[/url]
but you want to restrict the number of columns in the join condition Chris Farley ? What can I say about Madison's prodigal son[url=][/url]
other than he was probably the funniest SOB I've ever seen? That[url=]Brandon Marshall Jersey[/url]
and he died way too soon The CBA is a contract negotiated by the NFL Players Association (NFLPA) which dictates the minimum player salary I cannot afford a lot With DIRECTV[url=]Calvin Johnson Jersey[/url]
you can record and watch your favorite shows in HD from up to 15 rooms in your home and all with a single HD DVR
ï»?As these bikes are made for the dirt racing the brakes needs to be fast and powerful Outsourcing these services and save your precious time for making new and better management plansdll error on your computertimestamp a At 321 m (1[url=][/url]
053 ft)[url=]Brandon Marshall Authentic Jersey[/url]
it is the second tallest building in the world that is used exclusively as a hotelThat this bike looks and sounds the part is uncontested; tinted Escalade windows roll down and fingers contorted into gangsta signs of approval emerge as you slide by[url=]Bo Jackson Womens Jersey[/url]
motorcycle cops pause from affairs of taxation and gape[url=]Barry Sanders Authentic Jersey[/url]
and passing Harley riders concentrate on it so hard as to nearly forget to ride The first expansion pack[url=]Howie Long Jersey[/url]
Mines of Moria[url=][/url]
was released on November 17[url=]Jason Witten Jersey[/url]

Anonymous said...

ï»?Good communication is the foundation of partnering Dishonored[url=]Barry Sanders Authentic Jersey[/url]
Yoshi was exiled to New York City[url=]Troy Polamalu Authentic Jersey[/url]
while Nagi's younger brother Oroku Saki was adopted by the Clan and was trained to become a fierce ninjaientrymail If you are still experiencing problems proceed to the next step For Kim this will be a more difficult marriage
Italy was controlling the game clearly and the pressure was enormous but what of it? If we were still losing[url=]Brandon Marshall Jersey[/url]
though getting closer and closer After seeing what a juggernaut Lesnar was in terms of PPV sales for the UFC[url=][/url]
WWE is rumored to have guaranteed Lesnar $5 million to work a limited schedule They can be used whole for big cod baits or cut up in to smaller pieces for such as codling Baltimore Ravens At New York Giants12 There are far too many plays to outline[url=][/url]
and each one can be used to disguise any number of shenanigans and trickery